John Heilemann as placed an article
(Googlephobia) in New York
magazine describing the looming AAP vs. Google case very much from the publishers' perspective. Not any attempt at
sourcing a quote from Google seems to have been made. With that one-sidedness in mind, this piece carries a good
whallop of the indignation, righteous anger, frustration, and even glee experienced on the publisher side as this
battle shapes up.
From Pat Schroeder, head of the AAP: "Google approached our colleagues in music, movies, and broadcasting with the
same deal. They said, 'We're going to copy all your stuff and only use a snippet.' And our colleagues said, 'Oh yeah?
Do that and we'll sue.' I think Google believed those guys because they'd sued before, so Google let it go."
And from Simon & Schuster CEO Jack Romanos: "Google thought, Hey, if we can bully the publishing industry, we
can move into other forms of media. But the publishing industry has backbone—we're showing that right now. [...]I can't
speak for the industry, but I don't trust Google and Simon & Schuster doesn't trust Google. Why would you assume
that people who had taken the law into their own hands now would abide by the law in the future?"








1. Though the quotes are all from the publishing industry, the author himself supports Google's postition. Read to second half of the second page.
Posted at 4:42AM on Dec 19th 2005 by Huy